WtF: You've Been Playing a Character Your Whole Life

You know that feeling when you catch yourself in the mirror and for just a split second, you don't recognize the person staring back? That's not confusion—that's awakening.

"I spent years being who they wanted me to be. Now I get to discover who I actually am." - Sarah, age 34

The Truth About Identity Reconstruction

Your identity was likely built on a foundation of external validation and prescribed roles. The woman who was told her value came from purity, submission, and service is now free to discover her authentic desires, dreams, and definitions of success.

This isn't just healing—this is rebirth.

This issue, I’d like to tell you about one of my followers who told me her story and gave me permission to share it with you.

This is Jessica’s story. At 29, she was the poster child for "good Christian woman." Married at 22 to her college boyfriend (because you don't live in sin, obviously), working part-time so she could be home for her future children, attending three church services a week, and leading the women's Bible study on submission.

But Jessica had a secret: she was dying inside.

Every morning, she'd wake up feeling like she was putting on a costume. The modest dresses, the gentle smile, the way she'd defer to her husband even when she knew he was wrong about the restaurant directions. She'd catch herself mid-sentence, editing her thoughts before they became words, smoothing down any edge that might be considered "too much." If you’ve been in a high controlled religious environment, you know what Jessica means.

The breaking point came during a women's retreat when the speaker asked, "What brings you joy?" Jessica told me she sat there, pen hovering over paper, and realized she had no idea. She knew what was supposed to bring her joy—serving others, being a helper, making everyone else comfortable. But what actually lit her up? She couldn't remember the last time she'd even asked herself that question.

And you, dear reader, may still be wearing a costume so long you forgot it wasn't your skin. Every "good girl" smile, every swallowed opinion, every dream you buried because it wasn't "appropriate"—these weren't choices. They were survival strategies.

Understanding Your Conditioned Mind

Religious conditioning creates what psychologists call "introjected values"—beliefs you swallowed whole without questioning. These aren't your authentic values; they're survival mechanisms that helped you belong and feel safe.

Jessica's breakthrough came when she realized she'd been living someone else's life for so long, she'd forgotten she had permission to want things for herself. The guilt she felt when she bought that red lipstick? When she signed up for art classes without asking her husband first? And when she started saying "actually, I disagree" in conversations? That wasn't her conscience—that was her conditioning panicking.

Sister, if you were raised, or have been very involved, in a high control religious environment, you learned to monitor your thoughts before you even thought them. You developed an internal critic that sounds suspiciously like your pastor, your mother, or that youth group leader who made you feel small when you asked too many questions.

Here’s what I want you to know: Every time you feel guilty for wanting something "selfish," you're experiencing the conditioning trying to pull you back into the box. That guilt isn't your moral compass—it's your cage rattling.

Your authentic self has been buried under layers of "shoulds" and "shouldn'ts." She's been waiting patiently for you to excavate her. She's still there, beneath the performance, beneath the people-pleasing, beneath the fear of taking up too much space.

Jessica is now 34. She's divorced, runs her own business, travels solo, and wears whatever makes her feel powerful. Some days she misses the simplicity of having someone else's rulebook to follow. But she'd never go back to being a stranger to herself.

The Art of Becoming: The "Who Am I Really?" Silhouette Exercise

Grab a piece of paper and draw two outlines of a woman's silhouette.

In the first one, write or draw all the roles, expectations, and identities that were placed on you. Fill her completely - daughter, wife, helper, quiet tone, good girl, servant, peacekeeper, never-too-loud, always-available.

In the second silhouette, leave her completely empty except for one word in the center: "ME."

Now here's the powerful part: Look at that empty silhouette and resist the urge to fill her up immediately. Sit with the spaciousness. Feel the difference between being suffocated by others' expectations and having room to breathe, to discover, to become.

That empty space isn't lacking—it's potential. It's every dream you haven't dreamed yet, every boundary you haven't set, every "no" that will become a powerful "yes" to yourself.

 3 Ways to Begin Reclaiming Your Authentic Self

60-Second Energy Reset: The Identity Clearing Technique

Place one hand on your heart, one on your solar plexus (just below your ribcage). Close your eyes and breathe deeply three times.

Now, imagine golden light flowing down from the crown of your head, washing away every identity that isn't truly yours. With each exhale, release: "I am not my conditioning." With each inhale, declare: "I am discovering who I really am."

Why this works: According to energy medicine pioneer Donna Eden, the heart and solar plexus are your personal power centers. When you consciously connect with them while setting intention, you're literally rewiring your energy system to support your authentic identity rather than your conditioned one.

Ready to dive deeper? Join other women just like you reconstructing their identities in our private Facebook community, The Mystical Meadows. It's where the real conversations happen—the ones that would make your old church clutch their pearls.

And if you're ready for a roadmap out of religious trauma, grab your copy of "Unchurching the Soul: A Healing Guide to Healing After Religion" here. It's the ebook I wish I'd had when I was sitting in that pew, suffocating on someone else's version of who I should be.

Memes that Preach (better than a pulpit)

PS. Love Note from Me:

Sweet sister, I see you there—caught between who you were told to be and who you're discovering yourself to be. The discomfort you're feeling isn't a sign you're doing something wrong. It's growing pains. You're expanding beyond the container they built for you, and that takes courage most people will never understand.

Your authentic self is not a rebellion against God—she's a return to the truth of who you were created to be before the world got its hands on you.

Keep going. The woman you're becoming is worth every uncomfortable moment of this becoming.

All my love, Debby

The Mystical Meadows

Learn AI in 5 minutes a day

What’s the secret to staying ahead of the curve in the world of AI? Information. Luckily, you can join 1,000,000+ early adopters reading The Rundown AI — the free newsletter that makes you smarter on AI with just a 5-minute read per day.

Sign up to start learning.